Mackinac’s Best Fudge

Mackinac Island & Mackinaw City, Michigan

Our Fudge Flavors

Joann’s Fudge has an array of delicious flavors that are handcrafted on premises. In addition to our regular selection, we often introduce special seasonal flavors so keep checking to see what’s new.

Butter Pecan

Butter Pecan fudge

Rich, buttery sweetness perfectly balanced with crunchy pecans

Butterfinger

Butterfinger fudge

Chocolate fudge loaded with crunchy Butterfinger candy bar bits

Chocolate

Chocolate fudge

Our timeless classic – creamy, rich & bursting with pure chocolate flavor

Chocolate Cherry

Chocolate Cherry fudge

Juicy Traverse City cherries mixed throughout rich chocolate

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Chocolate Peanut Butter fudge

The ultimate duo of creamy, rich chocolate and smooth peanut butter

Chocolate Pecan

Chocolate Pecan fudge

Classic combination of chocolate packed with crunchy pecans

Chocolate Toffee

Chocolate Toffee fudge

The perfect blend of creamy chocolate and crunchy butter toffee

Chocolate Turtle

Chocolate Turtle fudge

Classic chocolate with ribbons of luscious caramel & crunchy pecans

Chocolate Walnut

Chocolate Walnut fudge

The perfect balance of rich chocolate & premium walnuts

Double Dark Chocolate

Double Dark Chocolate fudge

Packed with deep, velvety, chocolatey richness

Double Dark Chocolate Cherry Walnut

Double Dark Chocolate Cherry Walnut fudge

Rich chocolate with Traverse City cherries & crunchy walnuts

Double Dark Chocolate Espresso

Double Dark Chocolate Espresso fudge

Bold, fresh-ground espresso beans blended into luxurious chocolate

Double Dark Chocolate Mint

Double Dark Chocolate Mint fudge

Cool mint meets intensely rich deep chocolate goodness

Double Dark Chocolate Pecan

Double Dark Chocolate Pecan fudge

Deep, velvety, chocolate richness with the delightful crunch of pecans

Double Dark Chocolate Salted Caramel

Double Dark Chocolate Salted Caramel fudge

Rich chocolate pairs with smooth caramel & a touch of premium sea salt

German Chocolate

German Chocolate fudge

The rich flavors of chocolate, sweet coconut & crunchy pecans

Maple

Maple fudge

Sweet, rich maple taste that embodies the flavors of northern Michigan

Maple Walnut

Maple Walnut fudge

Velvety smooth classic maple flavor loaded with premium walnuts

Orange Truffle

Orange Truffle fudge

Double dark chocolate infused with bright, tangy orange flavor

Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter fudge

With the finest confectioners' peanut butter, it’s creamy & smooth

Penuche Pecan

Penuche Pecan fudge

An old-fashioned praline-tasting fave with brown sugar & pecans

Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie fudge

Seasonal essence of the holidays with comforting flavors of pumpkin pie

Raspberry Truffle

Raspberry Truffle fudge

Fruity raspberry richness infused into decadent double dark chocolate

Rocky Road

Rocky Road fudge

Rich chocolate packed with crunchy walnuts & gooey marshmallows

Vanilla

Vanilla fudge

Infused with the smooth, rich taste of French vanilla

Vanilla Pecan

Vanilla Pecan fudge

Creamy vanilla fudge blended with premium crunchy pecans

Vanilla Salted Caramel

Vanilla Salted Caramel fudge

Sweet & salty smooth caramel layers paired with premium sea salt

Order Your Fudge

Fudge & more...choose your perfect treat

Five Slice Box of Fudge $46.95

Shop

Four Slice Box of Fudge $42.95

Shop

Three Slice Box of Fudge $33.95

Shop

Two Slice Box of Fudge $25.95

Shop

One Slice Box of Fudge $12.95

Shop

Joann's Special $46.95

Shop

Cashew Brittle $10.95

Shop

Peanut Brittle $9.95

Shop

Ultimate Brittle $10.95

Shop

Salt Water Taffy $10.95

Shop

Fudge of the Month – Six Months $128.00

Shop

Fudge of the Month – Three Months $64.00

Shop

Give the gift of fudge this Christmas.
We have Gift Cards!

Gift Cards
Joan and Frank Nephew, then and now

Made With Love in Michigan

A Sweet Tradition Since 1969

Joann’s Fudge is a longstanding family business with deep ties to the community. Joan and Frank Nephew opened the first Joann’s Fudge Store on Mackinac Island in 1969. One year later they added a second location and in 1980, they added a third.

Today, Joann’s Fudge is a third-generation family business that continues Joan and Frank’s commitment to providing high-quality products. We pride ourselves on everything we make.

To get the taste we’re known for, our fudge is slowly cooked in traditional copper kettles over a gas flame. Once the desired temperature is reached, the mixture is poured onto marble slabs for a cooling period and then hand-paddled into loaves.

We only use fresh heavy cream and butter in every batch of fudge and pure ground cocoa beans in all our chocolate flavors. Joann’s Fudge does not contain any preservatives or powdered ingredients.

More About Us

Give a Taste of Michigan

Custom Favors & Gifts

Don’t hesitate to reach out to us for custom wedding favors or corporate gifts. We want to help you shower your loved ones with our delicious fudge in a way that they will always remember.

Learn More

Fudge of the Month

Want to savor Joann’s Fudge after you leave the Island or share the experience with someone else? Gift fudge to yourself or others – choose six months or three – choose your flavors!

Shop Now
A personalized fudge favor box on a gold charger plate at a wedding place setting

What People Are Saying

In our opinion, best fudge on Mackinac Island

We have been coming to Mackinac Island for years, and the fudge we prefer is JoAnn’s. Fresh and creamy, with wonderful, friendly staff. Hand dipped ice cream is here as well, and staff offers free tastes of any of the fudge varieties so you can purchase your favorite. My wife refuses to get fudge at any shop other than Joann’s. Highly recommended.

Joseph H

Wedding Favors

We used Joann’s Fudge for our wedding favors and were very happy with how they turned out. The guests raved about the double dark espresso fudge and many had finished them before the night was over. Sue was prompt and professional in her responses. A special detail for our wedding day we loved!

Wedding fudge boxes – they’re the best!

Joann’s did wedding fudge for our reception. They did an amazing job and embossed 150 boxes with our names and wedding date to give out at the reception. There was a slight hiccup in the printing but they corrected it and then some. Just wanted to show my appreciation for them making everything more than right immediately and say they have the best selection in fudge and did awesome with our wedding fudge boxes! highly recommend

Emily

Delicious fudge

The fudge here is so delicious. So many flavors. They also give you large sample sizes. We sampled fudge at many of the stores. A lot of people say this is the creamiest fudge.

Kkbwmn

Yummy fudge in so many flavors!

Friendly spot with helpful staff. Loved to watch the fudge making process when the staff were out! So many flavors to choose from and you can get a tasting to make sure it is what you are expecting. We ended up buying 5 fudge slices – chocolate, raspberry truffle, turtle, chocolate pecan, and salted caramel as that is the best value. Our vendors use a buy 4, get 1 free for the same price, so if you buy less than 4, JoAnn’s is a better value. Nice souvenir from Mackinac Island.

Jane G