Frequently Asked Questions

Ordering and shipping, wedding and party favors, and Fudge of the Month.

6 questions

Ordering & Shipping

How fast we ship, how your fudge is packed and stored, returns and payment.

Orders are shipped via USPS Priority Mail within two business days. Once your order has shipped, you will receive a USPS tracking number. While most deliveries arrive within three business days, please allow up to five days. If you’re ordering for a special occasion, we recommend placing your order with extra time to ensure it arrives perfectly.

Each slice is individually wrapped, and the box is protected with bubble wrap to ensure your package arrives in excellent condition.

For larger orders, UPS may offer more cost-effective shipping options. Please contact us directly for a custom shipping quote. We are happy to assist in finding the best shipping method to ensure your products arrive promptly and affordably.

Contact us ›

To maintain the rich, creamy texture of our fudge, wrap it in plastic or an airtight container at room temperature. Your fudge will stay fresh for up to three weeks. Do not refrigerate, as it will dry out the fudge.

For longer storage wrap your fudge in foil or freezer wrap and simply thaw it at room temperature when you’re ready to enjoy. Fudge can be frozen for up to six months.

At Joann’s Fudge, your happiness is our top priority! If for any reason you’re not completely satisfied with your purchase, please let us know. We’re more than happy to offer a replacement or a refund to make things right.

If you need to cancel an online order, we can help if the order hasn’t shipped yet. Feel free to get in touch, and we’ll assist you with the process.

Return/Cancellation Policy ›

We process all payments securely and accept all major credit cards.

8 questions

Wedding & Party Favors

Custom favor boxes for weddings, showers and other events: designs, pricing, timing and flavors.

Yes! We offer a wide range of box colors, font styles, font colors, and designs to coordinate with your event. Please click on the individual links on the website to explore the custom options.

If you have a custom design for your favor box, please email the design in JPEG file format.

Each favor box measures 2 ½” x 2 ½” x 1 1/8” and holds approximately 2.75 ounces of fudge or 4 truffles.

Request favors ›

We recommend placing your order at least 4-6 weeks before your event to ensure timely delivery and customization. Rush orders may be possible; please contact us for details.

Absolutely! You can choose one or more fudge flavors for your favor boxes. While there is only one flavor per favor box, you can select a variety of flavors for your overall order. Please contact us if you’d like to offer more than five fudge flavors for your event.

Each favor will have the flavor labeled on the bottom of the box for easy identification.

Yes, we offer truffles as an alternative to fudge. Each favor box holds 4 truffles. Please reach out to us for a list of available truffle flavors.

We offer complimentary delivery for events on Mackinac Island. Please include your desired delivery date and time on the Request Form.

For off-island events, we ship via UPS. Once your order has been shipped, you will receive an email with your tracking number and the shipping cost.

If you need shipping to multiple locations, we can arrange that as well. Simply provide the necessary details during the order process, and we’ll ensure your favors arrive at the correct destinations.

Fudge can be kept fresh for up to three weeks if wrapped in plastic and stored at room temperature. For longer storage, wrap the fudge in foil and freeze. Do not refrigerate, as it can dry out the fudge.

3 questions

Fudge of the Month

How the monthly club works, when boxes ship and how many flavors come in each.

Enjoy one pound of Joann’s fudge delivered to you or a loved one each month for three or six months. Please specify in your order which month to begin shipping, and choose your favorite flavors for each delivery.

Join Fudge of the Month ›

Fudge of the Month shipments are sent out on the first of each month. If you’d prefer a different start date, kindly indicate it in the special instructions box at checkout.

Each monthly box holds two flavors of your choice, picked when you order.

Still have a question?

Call 906.430.8635 or send us a message.